|

|
This
issue was sponsored by Abbott Laboratories S.A (PTY)
LTD
All Abbott products are lactose and gluten free
Tel: +27 (0)11 8582054
|
|
 |
|
|
Contents
A. Case study
B. More information
C. Editors' comments
D. References
E. CPD questions |
|
Index
A. Case study
The following case presentation was loosely modified and
adapted from the following article in order to maximise the reader’s
learning experience: Biagi et al. A milligram of gluten a day keeps
the mucosal recovery away: a case report. Nutr Rev. 2004 Sep; 62 (9):
360-3 & Nutr Rev 2004 Dec; 62 (12): 490-491
A
36-year-old nun was admitted to hospital complaining of diarrhoea, abdominal
pain and weight loss. On admission her BMI was 19 kg/m² (normal
BMI range for >35 years: 21-27 kg/m²). She had a history
of iron deficiency anemia over the past 10 years, with fatigue, hair
loss and koilonychia (thin, concave nails with raised edges, a clinical
feature of iron deficiency anaemia), which was treated with intravenous
iron supplementation. When questioned further about her medical history,
she reported failure to thrive in childhood and late menarche.
Laboratory tests
revealed the following:
• Hemoglobin: 10 g/dL (normal: 12 – 15.5 g/dL)
• Serum iron: 3.7 µmol/L (normal: 10 – 30 µmol/L)
• Ferritin: 5 µg/L (normal: 12 – 150 µg/L)
• Liver function tests: mildly raised transaminases
She
still therefore demonstrated iron deficiency anemia. Levels of folate
were not reduced, and vitamin B12 was normal, ruling out other causes
of anaemia.
QUESTIONS
AT THIS POINT:
It is necessary to establish the extent and time frame of weight loss.
More than 10% weight loss over 3-6
months is considered significant. If the patient does not know the exact
amount, the following questions may be asked to gauge the severity of
weight loss and the risk of undernutrition:
•
What is your normal weight?
• Have you unintentionally lost weight recently?
• A drop in clothes size or looser belt (change in belt notch)
may indicate weight loss:
______- A drop in 1-2 clothes sizes or
tightening of 1-2 belt notches would indicate 3-6 kg weight loss
______- >2 clothes sizes or >2-3
belt notches could indicate > 6 kg weight loss
• Have you been eating less than usual?
• Do you experience difficulties in eating, or are you able to
eat normally?
• Do you experience any diarrhoea or vomiting?
• Do you have a good appetite?
• How many times a day do you eat, and how much of the plate of
food do you eat?
On
questioning, it was established that the patient had experienced severe,
ongoing weight loss.
The next step was to eliminate causes of iron deficiency anemia:
• Chronic loss of blood due to GIT bleeding or excessive menstrual
loss
• Inadequate iron intake due to poor diet
• Impaired iron absorption
• Unmet increased requirements, as seen in children, adolescents,
and pregnant and lactating women
• Inadequate utilisation of iron due to chronic inflammation or
disease
• Defects in release from iron stores
The
patient revealed a history of chronic diarrhoea (>4 loose or watery
stools daily), which she had never been able to diagnose but through
the years had managed to cope with. She had started menstruating after
the age of 16 years and had an irregular cycle, with no marked losses.
A diet history revealed inadequate iron intake.
WHAT
DOES A PRACTITIONER DO AT THIS STAGE?:
Stools need to be tested for occult blood and pathogenic organisms.
Malabsorption syndromes such as celiac disease should be ruled out.
Celiac
disease screening tests, including endomysial and gliadin antibody tests,
were found to be positive, and the diagnosis was confirmed with a duodenal
biopsy, which revealed villous atrophy and a flat small bowel mucosa.
Guidelines
for a gluten-free diet as well as appropriate dietary sources of iron
and vitamin C were given by a dietitian. Iron and vitamin C supplementation
were prescribed.
The
patient returned to hospital 15 months later. Her diarrhoea and abdominal
pain had stopped, and weight loss had reversed. Transaminases were normal,
revealing good liver function; however, iron deficiency anemia, fatigue
and endomysial antibodies were still present.
QUESTIONS
AT THIS POINT:
Although many symptoms have improved, the ongoing anemia, fatigue and
positive celiac disease screening test could imply the following:
• Poor compliance in gluten-restricted diet, as well as continued
inadequate dietary intake of iron
• Possible hidden sources of gluten in the diet
• Suboptimal iron supplementation, and therefore a lack of improvement
in serum levels
A
thorough dietary assessment revealed that she had adequate iron sources
but had in fact not been following a strict gluten-free diet. She was
taking a daily communion wafer (made from wheat flour) and had had several
dietary lapses, as she did not want to inconvenience others. Analysis
of various products in her present diet that were thought to be gluten-free,
e.g., the oats she ate every second morning, showed wheat contamination.
It was therefore felt that her lack of improvement could be attributed
to her incorrect diet.
Unfortunately,
she refused to stop taking a daily fragment of communion wafer, despite
suggestions of alternative gluten-free wafers and discussions on the
importance of complete gluten avoidance. According to the Catholic Church,
the wafers must be made with wheat flour. It was decided to assess how
much gluten was in the wafer, as certain patients with celiac disease
may have a tolerance threshold. Hidden sources and contaminated foods
were identified, and she was advised to eliminate them. The monastery
was contacted to ensure that gluten-free meals could be prepared for
her.
Investigation
of the communion wafer fragments revealed a weight of 30 mg each, and
an ELISA test was used to measure the amount of gliadin. The mean amount
was found to be 1.76 g gliadin/100g. This corresponded to 3.52 g gluten/100g.
A 30 mg fragment of communion wafer therefore contained approximately
0.5 mg gliadin (1 mg gluten). It was felt that this small amount could
be tolerated.
Eighteen
months later, the nun returned for a routine follow-up and a second
duodenal biopsy to reveal histological recovery. Mucosal repair is important
in celiac patients, as ongoing atrophy and damage leads to an increased
risk for developing intestinal lymphoma.
A
dietary intake diary revealed that she was following a strict gluten-free
diet apart from the daily intake of the communion wafer fragment. Her
diet consisted almost entirely of natural foods and a few approved gluten-free
commercial products. Her anemia had disappeared, and celiac antibodies
were negative. Multiple duodenal biopsies, however, revealed persistence
of severe villous atrophy and an increased number of intraepithelial
lymphocytes.
WHAT
COULD THE CAUSE BE?
• The intake diary may be inaccurate, and she may actually be
eating more gluten-containing foods than recorded.
• She may still not be adhering to a gluten-free diet.
• She could be sensitive to even the small amount of gluten in
the communion wafer.
• She may have refractory/complicated celiac disease.
WHAT
CAN WE DO?
Her diet may have been contaminated by undetected gluten; however, examination
of the foods recorded showed very little to no contamination in the
products. This showed that contamination was an unlikely cause of the
lack of mucosal recovery. Her diet was also found to be gluten-free
in other respects, except for the communion wafer. The good dietary
adherence as well as the patient’s remarkably good clinical condition
made it highly unlikely that she was affected by complicated celiac
disease and suggested that the daily intake of 0.5 mg gliadin for a
2 year period was the reason for poor mucosal recovery.
Only
the withdrawal of the fragment of the communion wafer followed by a
duodenal biopsy would confirm whether such a small amount of gluten
was responsible for the lack of mucosal recovery.
SUGGESTIONS:
Permission could be obtained for the nun to be allowed to eat gluten-free
communion wafers, made without wheat flour.
 |
|
TIP for Allergy
Advisor users:
To distinguish between the various adverse reactions a person
can have to wheat and/or gluten, Allergy Advisor has developed
an information sheet. To find it in the program, click on
the “Management” bar, choose “Patient information
sheets”, click on “Food” and then “Adverse
reactions to wheat and gluten”. There is a part I and
II that follow on each other. |
|
B. More information:
Adverse
reactions to wheat can be divided into the following:1
i. Immune reactions:
• Allergic immune reactions
_____- IgE-mediated responses
_____- Non-IgE-mediated cellular responses
• Non-allergic immune reactions
_____- Celiac Disease (CD) (producing IgA
and IgG antibodies)
_____- Non-CD enteropathy
ii. Intolerance
The focus of this newsletter
is the non-allergic immune reaction of Celiac Disease.
DID
YOU KNOW?
Celiac disease was first described in 1888 by an English doctor,
S. Gee. He identified a syndrome characterised by enteropathy,
growth inhibition, diarrhoea and malabsorption disorders in children.
He thought the large intestine was the primary organ affected;
hence the name.
In
1908, C. Herter described a similar disease, calling it intestinal
infantilism. It was only in the late 1940’s that a Dutch
paediatrician, W Dicke, described the body’s incapacity
for gluten uptake as the reason for chronic intestinal disease
in children. Celiac disease is now synonymous with gluten enteropathy,
intestinal infantilism, gluten intolerance, idiopathic steatorrhoea
(fat in stools due to fat malabsorption, resulting in light-coloured,
soft, bulky, foul-smelling stools), non-tropical sprue and Gee-Heubner-Herter
disease.2, 3
|
Epidemiology
and pathogenesis of Celiac disease
Celiac disease is widespread, occurring on 0.5-1% of the population,
and has been called the most common ‘food intolerance’ in
the world. A disease traditionally associated with European countries,
particularly Scandinavia, it is now commonly seen in populations of
European ancestry (North and South Americas, Australia), and in North
Africa, the Middle East and South Asia.4, 5, 6,
7, 8, 9 In adults, the prevalence appears to be 1 in 250-300,
while in children it may be as common as 1 in 100.4,
5, 10
Celiac
disease may occur at any age. In infants, symptoms will usually appear
only a few months after the introduction of foods containing gluten
into the diet (6-12 months); in adulthood, the onset is usually between
30-40 years.11, 12, 13, 14 After onset,
it is a life-long disorder. It tends to affect twice as many females
as males.12, 13
Celiac
disease is a disease resulting from an inappropriate T-cell-mediated
immune response against ingested gluten in genetically pre-disposed
individuals. It is caused by IgA- and IgG-mediated immune responses,
and approximately 90-95% of cases are linked to the HLA-DQ2 gene complex,
while 5-10% are seen in those with HLA DQ8 gene complexes. Sensitisation
and activation of the T-lymphocytes lead to inflammation and structural
alteration of the mucosal lining. The enzyme tissue transglutaminase
is one of the targets of the autoimmune response in celiac sprue. The
enzyme converts particular glutamine residues in gluten peptides into
glutamic acid, which results in a higher affinity of these peptides
for HLA-DQ2 or HLA-DQ8 (negative charges are preferred at anchor positions
in the peptide-binding groove of this molecule).3,
4, 6, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23
Clinical
manifestations and symptoms
Celiac disease can be considered a systemic immunological disease as
well as a gastrointestinal disorder with a wide spectrum of clinical
presentations. Classical, atypical, silent and latent forms of the disease
have been identified. Only 20-30% patients suffer from active-classical
form of the disease, while approximately 70-80% of cases in adults will
fall within the non-diagnosed, inactive forms. Celiac disease is usually
characterised by damage to the small intestinal mucosa. Symptoms vary
from mild gastrointestinal disturbances to severe growth impairment,
failure to thrive, foul-smelling diarrhoea, iron-deficiency anaemia,
oedema and signs of malabsorption.8, 15, 18, 23,
24
The
resulting gastrointestinal abnormalities differ in different gastrointestinal
regions. Oesophageal transit and gastric and gallbladder emptying are
delayed, while colonic transfer is faster. Gut motility disorders may
predispose the individual to bacterial overgrowth, contributing further
to symptoms in some undiagnosed celiacs, and to the persistence of symptoms
after initiation of a gluten-free diet. All gastro-intestinal disturbances
should, however, ultimately disappear with continued gluten avoidance.25
A
vast majority of sufferers (adults and children) demonstrate atypical
symptoms and may well remain undiagnosed. Symptoms could include recurrent
apthous stomatitis (mouth ulcerations 3),
herpetiformis dermatitis (a skin reaction to gluten; a form of celiac
disease with or without gastrointestinal symptoms; symmetrical blistering,
burning, itchy rash on various body surfaces1,
3, 11, 26 27, 28, 29), unexplained elevated liver enzyme
levels, sensory neuropathy and dental enamel hypoplasia. These manifestations
often occur in the absence of any ‘typical’ gastro-intestinal
symptoms.10, 30, 31, 32 The disease
is also associated with an increased risk of osteoporosis, infertility,
autoimmune diseases such as diabetes mellitus (type 1) and malignancy
diseases, especially lymphomas.9
The
onset of noticeable symptoms of Celiac disease seems to be dependent
on the following:
• Exposure to wheat when an infant is weaned (introduction of
solids)
• Familial/genetic predisposition
• A “trigger” mechanism. Suspected factors are emotional
stress, trauma such as surgery or pregnancy, over-exposure to wheat,
viral infection, other diseases, and even antibiotics.12,
13, 22, 28
Summary
of clinical disorders associated with celiac disease 33
| Gastrointestinal
Liver disease: transaminitis, hepatitis, fatty liver, primary
billary cirrhosis, cirrhosis
Recurrent aphthous mouth ulcers
Irritable bowel syndrome
Lymphocytic gastritis
Ulcerative jejunitis
Reflux oesophagitis
Small bowel adenocarcinoma |
Haemopoeitic
Anemia (iron, folate, vitamin B12 deficiency)
Coagulation disorders from vitamin K deficiency
IgA deficiency
Hyposplenism
T-cell lymphoma |
| |
|
Neurological
Peripheral neuropathy
Epilepsy
Ataxia (coordination disorder, due to damage to the cerebellum23)
Myelopathy |
Locomotor
Osteopenia
Arthritis/arthralgia |
|
|
Psychiatric
Depression
Schitzophrenia |
|
Dermatological
Dermititis herpetiformis
Psoriasis
Brown pigmentation of face and buccal mucosa |
|
Endocrine
Type 1 diabetes
Infertility in men and women
Recurrent, unexplained abortion
Thyroid disorders
Addison’s Disease (underactive adrenal glands which
produce insufficient amounts of corticosteroids49) |
|
Dental
Defects in tooth enamel, e.g., hypoplasia
|
| |
|
Renal
IgA nephropathy
|
Genetic
Down’s syndrome
|
Other
Finger clubbing
Pharyngeal and oesophageal carcinoma
Sjogren’s syndrome (chronic inflammatory disorder with excessive
dryness of the mucous membranes49)
Alopecia areata (sudden hair loss, usually in the scalp or beard.
Regrowth is not always guaranteed23)
|
Cardiovascular
Cardiomyopathy |
|
|
Diagnosis
and screening
The availability of more-sensitive and more-specific serological tests
(antigliadin, antiendomysial and antitransglutaminase antibodies) has
facilitated non-invasive screening methods and early intervention in
well-defined risk groups.4, 23Despite
the high frequency of false positives in at-risk adult groups, IgA gliadin
antibodies are still the best marker of celiac disease in children under
2 years. A positive biopsy of the small intestine (duodenum/jejunum),
revealing a flattened small bowel mucosa in serologically positive individuals,
is still, however, the gold standard for diagnosis. In response to a
gluten-free diet, a subsequent biopsy should demonstrate healing of
the mucosa.6, 15, 18, 23, 24, 34, 35
In certain groups of
patients, a gluten food challenge remains essential:22
i. Patients who have started a gluten-free diet without an initial diagnostic
biopsy
ii. Patients who originally underwent a technically poor biopsy or in
whom the histopathology is not classically that of celiac disease
iii. Patients who had infection or immunodeficiency at the time of the
original diagnostic biopsy
iv. Patients with a strong personal or family history of atopic disease
Treatment
& management
The most effective treatment for celiac disease in both adults and children
is complete elimination of gluten from the diet. Intestinal mucosa should
heal totally after removal of the aggravating gluten. Further damage
to the small intestine will occur every time gluten is consumed, regardless
whether symptoms are present or not.11, 12, 22,
27, 28, 29, 36, 37
Poor or no response to gluten avoidance could indicate incorrect diagnosis,
inappropriate adherence to the diet or an unresponsive phase of the
condition, requiring more-intensive medical intervention, perhaps including
corticosteroid treatment. Occasionally, the lack of response could indicate
development of complications, including ulcerative jejunitis or enteropathy-associated
T-cell lymphoma.38
The
failure to treat and manage celiac disease (whether overt symptoms are
present or not) by means of a strict gluten-free diet will place individuals
at risk of developing life-threatening lymphoma. It is in this light
that the dietary management of this disease should be viewed as essential.
What
is gluten, and where is it found?
Wheat, like all other foods, contains a number of proteins (more than
100, in this case).39 Wheat proteins
can be characterised by the following:
i. Solubility:
• water-soluble
• salt-soluble
• alcohol-soluble
• alcohol-insoluble11, 40
ii. Type of protein:
• albumins (water-soluble – differing from egg and milk
albumin)
• globulins (salt-soluble and water-insoluble)
• glutens, which are a combination of 2 protein fractions/epitopes,
namely:
_____- gliadins (28-42%), the major prolamin
(alcohol-soluble storage proteins of cereal grains with ______similar
structures) protein in wheat (soluble in 70-90% alcohol); the prolamin
fractions of wheat, ______rye and barley
are gliadin, secalin and hordein respectively.39,
41
_____- glutenins (42-62.5%), the major
glutelin proteins in wheat (soluble in dilute acid or alkali ______solutions)6,
27,
Gluten
is found in various grains, including wheat, barley and rye.5
The major proteins in wheat (albumin, globulin, gliadin and glutenin)
may vary in proportion according to the type of wheat.17,
11, 36, 37 Wheat flour contains between 7 and 12%
gluten proteins by weight.13 |
|
 |
Gluten
is found in various grains, including wheat, barley and rye.5
The major proteins in wheat (albumin, globulin, gliadin and glutenin)
may vary in proportion according to the type of wheat.17,
11, 36, 37 Wheat flour contains between 7 and 12% gluten
proteins by weight.13
The
gliadin fractions in gluten are responsible for the viscous consistency
when wheat flour is mixed with water to form dough. The glutenins provide
the elasticity in wheat baked products.42
Although gliadins and glutenins occur in similar amounts, it is certain
of the gliadin fractions of wheat gluten and similar prolamins found
in other grains (barley, triticale [wheat-rye hybrid], rye and oats)
that are responsible for the characteristic small intestine mucosal
damage seen in celiac disease.24, 29
The
gliadin proteins are divided into alpha, beta, gamma (all three being
toxic to persons with CD) and omega gliadins (non-toxic to persons with
Celiac disease).6, 40, 43, 44 Recently,
in vitro studies have suggested that the immunodominant gliadin fraction
may lie within the region of amino acids 57-75 of alpha-gliadins. The
toxicity of these peptides was also confirmed in vivo when adults on
a gluten-free diet, challenged with the peptide, demonstrated significant
deterioration in biopsy morphology.17
In
the future, knowledge of the specific wheat gliadin fractions that exacerbate
the condition may allow for the development of immuno-modulatory peptides
and cereals with the baking and nutritional qualities of wheat, rye
and barley but without harmful effects on susceptible individuals.17
Although
true gluten is found only in wheat, the term gluten is used to refer
to any similar prolamin proteins in other grains.
The
following shows the percentage of specific prolamins in other grains:
|
Grain |
Prolamin |
Percentage
of total protein |
|
Wheat |
Gliadin |
69 |
|
Corn |
Zein |
55 |
|
Barley |
Hordein |
46
- 52 |
|
Sorghum |
Kafirin |
52 |
|
Rye |
Secalinin |
30
- 50 |
|
Millet |
Panicin |
40 |
|
Oats |
Avenin |
16 |
|
Rice |
Orzenin |
5 |
| This
table illustrates the variety in the type and proportion of prolamins
amongst different grains. Each would result in a different reaction,
if any.12, 27, 29, 43 Corn, rice,
sorghum, millet, teff, and ragi, as well as buckwheat, quinoa and
amaranth, can safely be ingested by a person with Celiac disease.
Spelt and kamut, however, should be avoided in celiac disease.44,
45, 46 |
|
|
How
much gluten is safe?
Controversy has existed as to whether small amounts of gluten would
be detrimental to a celiac sufferer and still cause symptoms after a
period of gluten avoidance. It has been reported in the past that as
little as 0.1 grams of ingested gluten can trigger symptoms.1
Gluten
contamination in gluten-free products cannot be totally avoided; this
fact helps render the safe threshold for gluten still obscure. Individual
countries tend to show different amounts of residual gluten in gluten-free
products. In a recent study in Finland, an attempt was made to estimate
the reasonable limit for residual gluten, based on the current literature
and the measurement of gluten in ‘gluten-free’ products
on the market. A number of both naturally gluten-free and wheat starch-based
‘gluten-free’ products analysed contained gluten, from 20
to 200 ppm (20-200 mg/kg). The median flour consumption of the adults
in the study (n=76) following a gluten-free diet was 80g (range 10-300).
Within these limits, long-term mucosal recovery was good.7,
18, 47
The
study concluded that the threshold for gluten contamination could be
safely set at 100 ppm (100 mg/kg) gluten per day. If the daily flour
intake is 300g, a level of 100 ppm results in 30 mg gluten (gliadin)
intake. This amount still allowed improvement in histology in both clinical
and challenge studies. It is a level of ingestion that can be faciliated
by proper controls in the food industry and does not make the diet too
cumbersome.47
According
to the old Codex Alimentarius standard, for a product to be considered
gluten-free, it must contain less than 200-300 ppm (200 mg/kg) gluten.
There is, however, evidence to demonstrate that even smaller amounts
of gluten ingested on a regular basis by individuals with celiac disease
can lead to mucosal changes on intestinal biopsy. Controversy surrounding
what constitutes a ‘gluten free diet’ is the result of inaccurate
techniques for detecting gluten and the lack of sound scientific evidence
for a threshold of gluten consumption below which no harm occurs. As
a result, a new limit of 20 ppm (mg/kg) is being considered as defining
gluten-free in the proposed Codex Alimentarius,48
a level already implemented in Canada and in draft legislation in South
Africa.
Ultimately,
the safe limit in a diet should be evaluated individually. When mucosal
recovery is evident after 1 year on an apparently gluten-free diet,
the diet can be assumed to be strict enough. The diet must be practical
and realistic, as it is poor dietary compliance in the treatment of
celiac disease that seems to be more deleterious and common than the
adverse effects of trace amounts of gluten in otherwise gluten-free
products.49
How
safe are oats – what does the literature say?
The case for…..
 |
Whether oats
should be included in a gluten-free diet has been debated for half
a century. The amount of avenin in oats (10%) is relatively small
compared with the amounts of relevant prolamins present in wheat,
barley and rye (40-50%).16 |
It
has been established that gluten contains a number of T-cell stimulatory
peptides leading to the inflammatory events in the pathogenesis of celiac
disease. In 2003, a study attempted to identify similar T-cell stimulatory
peptides in barley, rye and oats in order to establish the actual toxicity
of these grains in the disease. It was possible to demonstrate T-cell
cross-reactivity between gluten peptides and related peptides in hordeins
and secalins, thus explaining toxicity of barley and rye respectively
in patients with celiac disease (all contain high amounts of glutamine
and proline residues).16, 41
Regarding
avenin in oats, differences were found between the peptides –
avenin lacks certain proline molecules, making it more susceptible to
degradation by proteases in the gastrointestinal tract. In a comparison
of the identified peptides of hordein, secalin and avenin, it was only
avenin peptides that were sensitive to breakdown. This rapid degradation
of the potentially harmful avenin peptides may help prevent initiation
of an immune response against oats in the small intestine. These findings
may pave the way for treatment of gluten enteropathy with an enzyme
specific for proline-rich sequences, to destroy the toxic properties
of gluten.16, 41
In
1995, in the largest and most scientifically robust study on the safety
of oats, investigators found no adverse effects associated with regular
consumption of moderate amounts of oats. Subsequent studies have concluded
without exception that intake of oats in varying quantities (range:
24-63g/day) in adults with celiac disease is safe.41
The
case against…..
Although oats themselves may be considered safe, it is of major concern
that they may often be contaminated with wheat, barley or rye. The extent
to which contamination of commercial oat products occurs is unknown,
and the quantity of oats consumed may be critical. It is estimated that
most commercial oat products contain wheat flour or gluten. Contamination
of oats with wheat may occur due to the sharing of equipment in grain
processing and the rotation of crops (wheat may be grown on the same
field as oats were).1, 41
On
histological grounds, no differences have been described between patients
on a traditional gluten-free diet and those on a more rigorous, non-detectable
gluten diet. A dose of 100 mg/day of gliadin administered for 1 month
is toxic to duodenal mucosa in susceptible individuals; however, there
is little known about the effects of smaller gliadin doses ingested
over a longer period of time. In recent case reports and a literature
review regarding the safety of commercial oats and the minimal amount
of gluten that could be harmless to celiac patients, it was shown that,
although most patients with celiac disease tolerated oats (controlled
for contamination) in their diet, a few patients exposed to food challenges
with pure oats developed changes in bowel habits and abdominal discomfort
or dermatitis.41, 50, 51
It
was also concluded that as little 1 mg of gluten ingested every day
for 2 years prevented histological/mucosal recovery in spite of satisfactory
clinical and serological responses. Mucosal recovery is the main protection
against the development of intestinal lymphoma, and therefore it is
suggested that a second duodenal biopsy should be done in all cases
following gluten restriction, to identify those patients with persistent
villous atrophy despite appropriate clinical and serological data.41,
50, 51
Practically…..
Authorities on celiac disease, however, are still reticent to advise
the safe intake of oats as an alternative to wheat. The Finnish Celiac
Society advocates the safe consumption of oats; in the UK, only healthy
adults on well-established gluten-free diets are told they can consume
oats, with amounts not exceeding 50g/day; all organisations in North
America continue to advise against the use of oats. Reasons include
methodological limitations in studies that have observed the lack of
toxicity of oats; observed immune response to oat prolamins in vitro,
and the possible contamination of commercial products with wheat, barley
and rye.41
In
patients likely to use oats, it is therefore advised that only products
tested and found to be free of contamination, or those within acceptable
limits for residual gluten, should be consumed. Practically, an amount
of approximately a half a cup of dry whole-grain rolled oats per day
is recommended. Ways to reduce chances of consuming contaminated oats
include avoiding oats sold in bulk from bins, and determining from the
manufacturers whether a dedicated line or facility is used for processing1,
41
| |
Compiled by Gina Stear
RD(SA)
Private Practising
Food & Allergy Consulting & Testing Services (FACTS)
PO Box 565
Milnerton 7435
South Africa |
C.
Comments by our editors
| Prof
Janice M. Joneja Ph. D., RDN
It
is extremely important that celiac disease be accurately diagnosed.
Undiagnosed disease can have significant adverse consequences
in a variety of organ systems, as this excellent article clearly
makes evident. On the other hand, an incorrect diagnosis, or assumption
based on insufficient evidence can result in a lifetime of unnecessary
dietary restriction. In my practice I have encountered a number
of patients who have made the assumption that they have celiac
disease, based on their reading of articles on the subject, and
advice from friends. They have thenceforth strictly avoided gluten-containing
foods, sometimes for a number of years. The problem has then arisen
that any tests for celiac disease will be invalid, since histological
and immunological markers will be absent as long as gluten is
avoided. In order to make a valid diagnosis the patient must consume
gluten for about four weeks prior to testing. I have found that
after several years of avoiding gluten, and adjusting to a specific
type of diet, the majority of self-diagnosed patients are extremely
reluctant to do this and elect to maintain a gluten-free diet
rather than take what they consider to be an unacceptable risk
by consuming what they now consider to be “poison”.
|
|
Dr. Harris
Steinman M.B.Ch.B.
Because
of the often non-specific symptoms of coeliac disease, it is crucially
important that health professionals bear this disease in mind
when evaluating patients for food related conditions. Any patient
with unresolved symptoms should alert the clinician to reflect
on this diagnosis similar to the way a doctor always asks a patient
whether they are penicillin allergic before prescribing this antibiotic.
|
For more information on this subject and other allergy- and intolerance-related
topics, visit:
www.allallergy.net
www.allergyadvisor.com
http://users.bigpond.net.au/allergydietitian
To
join a professional food allergy discussion list where this subject
can be discussed further, go to http://groups.yahoo.com/group/AllergyDietitian
or
Subscribe: AllergyDietitian-subscribe@yahoogroups.com
Unsubscribe: AllergyDietitian-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
Please
feel free to send this newsletter out to colleagues who are not subscribed.
To subscribe or unsubscribe, send an e-mail to astrid@factssa.com
and put “Subscribe Educational” or “Unsubscribe Educational”
as the subject.
D.
References
1. Gluten and grain intolerance, www.healthcomm.com
2. Lavrova TE. Clinical picture of celiac disease in children. Eksp
Klin Gastroenterol. 2003; (6): 40-5, 153.
3. Farrell RJ, Kelly CP. Celiac Sprue. N Engl J Med. 2002 Jan 17; 346
(3): 180-188.
4. Accomando S, Cataldo F. The global village of celiac disease. Dig
Liver Dis. 2004 Jul: 36 (7): 492-8.
5. Rousset H. A great imitator for the allergologist: intolerance to
gluten. Allerg Immunol (Paris). 2004 Mar; 36 (3): 96-100.
6. McManus R, Kelleher D. Celiac disease- the villain unmasked? N Engl
J Med. 2003 Jun 19: 348 (25) 2573-4.
7. Maki M et al. Prevalence of celiac disease among children in Finland.
N Engl J Med. 2003 Jun 19: 348 (25) 2517-25.
8. Prokopova L. Celiac disease-a severe disease. Vntr Lek. 2003 Jun;
49 (6): 449-51.
9. Green PH, Jabri B. Coeliac disease. Lancet 2003 Aug 2; 362 (9381):
383-91.
10. Bingley PJ, Williams AJK et al. Undiagnosed celiac disease at age
seven: population based prospective birth cohort study. BMJ 2004 Feb;
328: 322-323.
11. www.scienceinafrica.co.za
12. http://allergies.about.com/library/weekly/aa020899.htm
13. http://wheat.pw.usda.gov/ggpages/topics/
14. http://www.intelihealth.com/IH/ihtIH/WSIHW000/7945/24481/286178.html?d=dmtContent
15. Raanan S. Advances in celiac disease. Gastroenterol Clin N Am 2003;
32: 931-947.
16. Willemijn Vader L, et al. Characterisation of cereal toxicity for
celiac disease patients based on protein homology in grains. Gastroenterology
2003; 125: 1105-1113.
17. Ciclitira PJ. Recent advances in celiac disease. Clin Med. 2003
Mar-Apr; 3 (2): 166-9.
18. Fasano A. Editorials: Celiac disease-how to handle a clinical chameleon.
N Engl J Med. 2003 Jun 19: 348 (25) 2568-70.
19. Cardenas A, Kelly CP. Celiac Sprue. Semin Gastrointest Dis. 2002
Oct; 13 (4): 232-44.
20. Williamson D, Marsh MN. Celiac disease. Mol Biotechnol. 2002 Nov;
22 (3): 293-9.
21. Louka AS, Sollid LM. HLA in celiac disease: unravelling the complex
genetics of a complex disorder. Tissue Antigens. 2003 Feb; 61 (2): 105-17.
22. Metcalfe D, Sampson H, Simon R. Food Allergy: Adverse reactions
to foods and food additives 2nd edition. Blackwell Science, 1997: 288-301.
23. Berkow R, Beers M, et al. The Merck Manual. Home edition. Pocket
books, 1997: 536-7.
24. Catassi C, Fasano A. Celiac disease as a cause of growth retardation
in childhood. Curr Opin Pediatr. 2004 Aug; 16(4): 445-9.
25. Tursi A. Gastrointestinal motility disturbances in celiac disease.
J Clin Gastroenterol. 2004 Sep; 38 (8): 642-5.
26. Feighery C. Coeliac disease. BMJ 1999 July 24; 319: 236-9.
27. http://users.bigpond.net.au/allergydietitian/
28. www.gluten.net
29. Fasano A, Catassi C. Current approaches to diagnosis and treatment
of Celiac Disease: an evolving spectrum. Gastroenterol 2001;120: 636-651.
30. Pastore L, De Benedittis M, et al. Importance of oral signs in the
diagnosis of atypical forms of celiac disease. Recenti Prog Med. 2004
Oct; 95 (10): 482-90.
31. Abdo A et al. Liver abnormalities in celiac disease. Clin Gastroenterol
Hepatol. 2004 Feb; 2 (2): 107-12.
32. Chin RL, et al. Celiac neuropathy. Neurology 2003 May 27; 60 (10):
1581-5.
33. Duggan J. Coeliac disease: the great imitator. Med J Aust 2004 May
17; 180 (10): 524-526.
34. Sjoberg K, Carlsson A. Screening for celiac disease can be justified
in high-risk groups. Lakartidningen 2004 Nov 25; 101 (48): 3912, 3915-6,
3918-9.
35. Freeman HJ. Adult celiac disease and the severe “flat”
small bowel biopsy lesion. Dig Dis Sci. 2004 Apr; 49 (4): 535-45.
36. Joneja JV. Dietary management of food allergies and intolerances
– a comprehensive guide 2nd edition. J.A. Hall Publications Ltd.,
USA, 1998.
37. http://www.nutramed.com/celiac/gluten.htm
38. Cicilitira PJ, Moodie SJ. Transition of care between paediatric
and adult gastroenterology. Coeliac disease. Best Pract Res Clin Gastroenterol.
2003 Apr; 17 (2): 181-95.
39.Shewry PR, Halford NG. Cereal seed storage proteins: structures,
properties and role in grain utilization. Journal of Experimental Botany
2002;53(370):947-58.
40. Pomeranz Y. Wheat: chemistry and technology. American Association
of Cereal Chemists, Inc., USA, 1988.
41. Thompson T. Oats and the gluten-free diet. J Am Diet Assoc. 2003
Mar; 103 (3): 376-9.
42. Shewry PR, et al. The structure and properties of gluten: an elastic
protein from wheat grain. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2002 Feb
28; 357 (1418): 133-42.
43. http://www.csaceliacs.org/useofoats.html
44. Weiss W, Huber G, Engel KH, Pethran A, Dunn MJ, Gooley AA, Gorg
A. Identification and characterization of wheat grain albumin/globulin
allergens. Electrophoresis 1997;18(5):826-833.
45. Thompson T. Questionable foods and the gluten-free diet: Survey
of current recommendations. J Am Diet Assoc 2000: 100(4):463-5.
46. Kasarda DD. Grains in relation to Celiac (Coeliac) Disease. http://wheat.pw.usda.gov/ggpages/topics/
47. Collin P, Thorell L, et al. The safe threshold for gluten contamination
in gluten-free products. Can trace amounts be accepted in the treatment
of coeliac disease? Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 2004 Jun 15; 19 (12): 1277-83.
48. Hill et al. Guideline for the Diagnosis and Treatment of Celiac
Disease in Children: Recommendations of the North American Society for
Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition. J Ped Gastroenterol
Nutr 2005;40(1):1-19.
49. Kaukinen K, Collin P. Wheat starch and trace amounts of gluten in
the treatment of celiac disease. Working group on prolamin analysis
and toxicity – Proceedings of the 18th meeting. Oct 2003: 161-163.
50. Biagi F, Campanella J, et al. A milligram of gluten a day keeps
the mucosal recovery away: a case report. Nutr Rev. 2004 Sep; 62 (9):
360-3 & Nutr Rev 2004 Dec; 62 (12): 490-491.
51. Lundin K, Nilsen E, et al. Oats induced villous atrophy in celiac
disease. Gut 2003; 52: 1649-1652.
E. CPD Questions (For South African dietitians
only. Australian dietitians: where you have relevant
learning goals, CPD hours related to this resource can be included in
your APD log.)
| South
African dietitians can obtain 2 CPD points for
reading this newsletter (which has been accredited for dietitians)
and answering the accompanying questions.
CPD reference number: DT05/3/021/13
HOW TO EARN YOUR
CPD POINTS
1. Complete your personal details below.
2. Read the newsletter and answer all the questions.
3. Indicate your answers to the questions by making a “X”
in the appropriate block.
4. You will earn 2 CPD points if you answer more than 75% of the
questions correctly. If you score is between 60 and 75%, 1 CPD
point will be allocated. A score of less than 60% will unfortunately
not earn any CPD points.
5. Make a copy for your own records in case your answers do not
reach us.
6. Cut and paste the area indicated below into an e-mail message
and e-mail it to astrid@factssa.com
to be received no later than 31 May 2005. Answer sheets received
after this date will not be processed. |
PLEASE ANSWER ALL THE QUESTIONS
(There is only one correct answer per question.)
1. True or false: Celiac disease is also known as a wheat allergy.
(a.) True
(b.) False
2.
The gold standard for diagnosing celiac disease is:
(a.) Antiendomysial antibodies
(b.) Anti transglutaminase antibodies
(c.) Skin prick test
(d.) Serum blood tests
(e.) Small bowel biopsy
3. Which one of
the following is toxic to a person with Celiac Disease?
(a.) Corn
(b.) Rice
(c.) Quinoa
(d.) Spelt
4. Identify which
of the following clinical manifestations could be associated with gluten
sensitive enteropathy:
(a.) Iron deficiency anaemia
(b.) Short stature and failure to thrive
(c.) Recurrent mouth ulcerations
(d.) Neuropathy
(e.) All of the above
5. The prolamins
present in barley, rye and oats are:
(a.) Hordein, secalin and avenin
(b.) Glutenin, avenin and secalin
(c.) Avenin, hordein and secalin
(d.) Hordein, secalin and gluten
6. Studies have
concluded without exception that intake range of oats in adults with
celiac disease in the following quantities is safe:
(a.) 63-100 g/day
(b.) 24-63 g/day
(c.) 10-25 g/day
(d.) 100-110 g/day
7. True or false:
As little as 1 mg of gluten ingested every day for 2 years prevented
histological/mucosal recovery in spite of satisfactory clinical and
serological response.
(a.) True
(b.) False
8. In patients likely
to use oats, only products tested and found to be free of contamination
or those within acceptable limits for residual gluten should be consumed.
An amount of approximately 2 cups of dry whole-grain rolled oats per
day is recommended.
(a.) True
(a.) False
Cut and paste
this section below into an e-mail message
Celiac Disease
CPD Reference number: DT05/3/021/13
HPCSA number: DT
Surname as registered with the HPCSA: Initials:
E-mail address:
Please make an "X"
in the appropriate block for each question
| 1.
a [ ] b [ ] |
|
2.
a [ ] b [ ] c [ ] d [ ] e [ ] |
|
3.
a [ ] b [ ] c [ ] d [ ] |
| 4.
a [ ] b [ ] c [ ] d [ ] e [ ] |
|
5.
a [ ] b [ ] c [ ] d [ ] |
|
6.
a [ ] b [ ] c [ ] d [ ] |
| 7.
a [ ] b [ ] |
|
8.
a [ ] b [ ] |
|
|
Index
This
issue was sponsored by Abbott Laboratories S.A (PTY) LTD
All Abbott products are lactose and
gluten free
Tel: 011-8582054
|
|
 |
|